Showing posts with label Christianity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Christianity. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 20, 2019

Notes on "A History of Political Theory" -- Episode 20

For episode 19, see here

The Theory of the Nation State

XX. England: Preparation for Civil War
 A. Lines between rival political ideas not clearly drawn in early 17th Century
      England.
       1. No need to support royal absolutism with the theory of divine right.
       2. None had to seek theoretical defense for right to resist.
 B. Thomas Moore's Utopia (1516) was political satire expressing dislike of 
      growing acquisitive society.
       1. Harked back to Platonic conception of community of cooperative
           classes.
       2. Illustrated "looking back" from coming economic age.
 C. Richard Hooker argued that Puritan refusal of obedience to establish church
      was denying all political obligation.
       1. Reason was accepted universally as soon as it was understood.
       2. Law of reason was manifestly binding on all men.
       3. Man cannot satisfy all their needs in isolation and therefore form society.
       4. Ground of political obligation is common consent by which men agreed
           to be ordered by someone.
       5. Society could never withdraw its consent to authority it has set up after
           the fact.
       6. Ecclesiastical law of England not contrary to Christian faith and therefore
           binding -- as was all law -- upon all Englishmen.
 D. Calvinists and Catholics objected to royal supremacy in the Church as an 
      invasion of it's spiritual independence.
 E. Independents split church from state, seeing the former as a voluntary
     association.
 F. Erastianism of John Seldon saw the relationship between religion and the
     king in utilitarian, secularist and rational terms not common or typical
     for times.
 G. King, courts and Parliament each seen as having inherent powers, none
      claimed supremacy until the civil war.
 H. First conflict between king and courts over royal prerogative.
       1. Francis Bacon defended the right of the King to overrule the courts.
       2. Chief Justice Edward Coke argued for supremacy of common law over
           the King and Parliament.
      3. Coke saw law as indigenous growth within the realm that defined all
          rights and obligations.

Next week:  Thomas Hobbes


     

Wednesday, October 16, 2019

Notes on "A History of Political Theory" -- Episode 16

For episode 15, see here

The Theory of the National State

XVI: The Early Protestant Reformers 
 A. Reformation mixed political theory with differences of religious 
     belief and questions of theological dogma.
 B. Diversity of religious belief did not lead to toleration because all
     still saw themselves as right and their opponents as stupid
     and/or wicked.
 C. Religious reform and conflict depended on secular power thus
     strengthening royal power.
 D. Under the surface were strong minority groups that were potential
     sources of disorder.
       1. Out of diversity and necessity, minority groups led towards
          mutual political toleration 
       2. Right to resist "heretical" pope became right to resist a
          "heretical" king
 E. Led to conflict between divine right and popular right, both
     originally grounded in theology
 F. Martin Luther
       1. Remade arguments and charges of past centuries, especially
          the conciliar controversy
          i. saw church as the assembly of all believers 
          ii. saw clergy as serving callings useful to the community
           and answerable in temporal matters
       2. Using government to reform the Church led to creation of
           national churches 
       3. Asserted duty of passive obedience to the ruler
       4. Stressed other-worldliness of religion with acquiescence to
           worldly power 
 G. Calvinism and the power of the church 
       1. Impact of sect in opposition to specific governments meant
           the spread of the justification of resistance 
       2. Viewed the church as the standard bearer of morals with
           secular power as the enforcing arm; as in the Middle Ages
       3. Taught self-control and discipline in the struggle of life
       4. God seen as sovereign, saving men by fore-ordination rather
           than own good works
       5. Secular institutions existed as the "external means of salvation"
       6. Not given to monarchical attachments, therefore often in
           opposition to the monarchy 
 H. John Calvin taught passive obedience to secular authority, had
     no theory of popular rights
 I. John Knox turned supremacy of the church to mode of resistance
     to the state (Scotland) that did not recognize "true faith"
       1. This involved rejection of passive obedience
       2. Resistance became part of the duty to sustain religious reform

Next week: Royalist and anti-Royalist Theories
     

Wednesday, September 18, 2019

Notes on "A History of Political Theory" -- Episode 13

For episode 12 see here


The Theory of the Universal Community


XIII.  Universitas Hominum
  A. Rebirth of scholarly activity in 13th Century
       1. rediscovery of Aristotle
       2. concentration on theology and metaphysics
  B. John of Salisbury
       1. saw kings bound by law as everyone was
       2. carried on argument of Cicero for res publica
       1. used Aristotle as new support for Christian philosophy
       2. tried to synthesize faith and reason
       3. saw each as acting to achieve own form of perfection within a
           hierarchy of degrees of perfection
       4. saw Aristotelian society of mutual exchange for achieving the good life
       5. ruler derives power from his part, under God, in the community of
           directing every class towards a happy and virtuous life
       6. offered no clear definition of lawful authority or of its derivation (or the
           kings relation to law)
       7. law was one aspect of the cosmic system by which God rules the world
           i. all different manifestations of the same principles
           ii. Eternal Law -- the eternal plan of all creation, not knowable
           iii. Natural Law -- reflection of Eternal Law in created things
           iv. Divine Law -- revelation from God in the Scriptures
           v. Human Law -- ius gentium and ius civile, applies to humankind the
           divine principle
       8. Human Law is Natural Law made to cover man


"For both men [Aquinas and Locke], the ruler is as definitely bound by reason and justice as his subjects, and his power over the positive law arises from the need of keeping it in agreement with Natural Law. Enactment is less an act of will than an adjustment to times and circumstances. (259)


 D. Dante sought to show the Emperor's authority derived directly from God but
      not dependent on God.
 E. For all three thinkers, human race forms a single community whose existence
     implies a single head.
 F. Out of line with Aristotle's presumption that the state is an outgrowth of the
     natural evolution of society, justified by the moral values it sustains without
     religious sanction.


Next week: Three Challenges to Christian Society    


Wednesday, August 28, 2019

Notes on "A History of Political Theory" -- Episode 10


For episode 9 see here

 The Theory of the Universal Community

 X. Seneca and the Fathers of the Church

    A. Seneca wrote in the early days of Empire
    B. Reflects despondence of a Rome in social and political decline 
    C. Good man can do nothing through political office and such offices
         have little to offer good men
     D. Duty of the good man is to offer moral or religious virtue, to become
          the teacher of mankind
       1. offered strength and consolation in this world
       2. turned toward contemplation of spiritual life
       3. beginning of split between religious life and politics
     E. Religious institutions begin to form along side state
     G. State no longer seen as highest agency of moral perfection 
     H. Seneca saw innocent Golden Age, a state of nature
      I.  For him, government and law are an ethical second-best and as a cure for
           the sinfulness of civilized man
      J. Rise of Christian Church as distinct institution to govern spiritual
          concerns of men was revolutionary
       1. Religious doctrine of salvation was neither philosophy nor political theory
       2. Philosophy of early Christians not unlike Stoics  
          i. law of nature
          ii. providential government of the world
          iii. obligation of law and government to serve justice 
          iv. equality of all men before God
       3. Added obligation to respect constituted authority, as derived from God,
          not the people
          i. respect due institution, not merely the person of the ruler
          ii. But unlike Roman law, it was necessary to suffer bad ruler as he came
              from God and not the people
          iii. Yet obligation to God higher than obligation to the state
       4. Christianity split what for pagans was a unity -- that the duties of
          morality and religion met in the state
       5. Led to problems of church and state (which made possible liberty)
       6. Church and State were to be mutually interdependent with the Church
          the superior partner
     K. Ambrose, Augustine and Gregory
       1. Dealt not with systemic philosophy of Church and State but with
         immediate pressing problems
       2. Ambrose -- 4th Century AD
          i. strong statement for autonomy of the Church in spiritual matters
          ii. taught and converted Augustine
       3. Augustine -- 5th Century AD
          i. transmitted ancient thought to Middle Ages
          ii. Saw human history as dominated by contest between earthly city
              (lower human nature) and the City of God
          iii. through earthly life, however, the two cities are mingled
          iv. true commonwealth must be Christian as only such a state is just
       4. Gregory -- pope, father of the medieval papacy
          i. obedience to ruler extended to passive obedience to wicked ruler
          ii. ruler had power even to do what was unlawful, providing he was
             willing to risk damnation
       5. The Two Swords
          i. Church held spiritual interests and eternal salvation which was the
           province of teaching by clergy
          ii. State held temporal authority, maintenance of peace, order and
           justice
          iii. between the two a spirit of mutual helpfulness ought to prevail
       6. Universal Christian society was the Empire and the Universal Church,
       7. Split laid the ground for the right of (spiritual) freedom
 

Next week: The Folk and Its Law